UK Law Firms Eyeing US Market: A New Dawn Or Familiar Frustration?

UK law firms have long dreamt of cracking the US market, but the path has been littered with challenges. With the recent A&O Shearman merger, could 2024 be the year they finally break through?

Updated: 27th February 2024

The legal landscape is shifting, with global law firms experiencing significant growth in size and numbers. For UK firms, the allure of the US market, the pinnacle of the legal world, is undeniable. Entering this market represents a logical step towards true global dominance, offering numerous benefits:

  • Brand expansion and global client reach: Accessing the US market would significantly expand brand recognition and attract a broader clientele, solidifying a truly global presence.
  • Presence in key financial and business centers: Major US cities like New York and Los Angeles are hubs for international finance and business. Establishing a presence in these centers grants access to a critical mass of potential clients.
  • Meeting the needs of multinational clients: Many UK firms already serve multinational clients with global operations. Having a US presence enables them to better meet their clients' needs across all jurisdictions.

However, despite the evident advantages, breaking into the US market has proven notoriously difficult for UK firms. The "Magic Circle," a group of five prestigious UK firms, has faced consistent challenges in establishing a significant foothold in the US, often finding themselves overshadowed by well-established domestic giants.

A&O Shearman: A Beacon of Change?
There are, however, signs of a potential shift in the tide. The recent merger of Magic Circle firm Allen & Overy (A&O) with US giant Shearman & Sterling, creating Allen Overy Shearman Sterling (A&O Shearman), could signal a new approach for UK firms. This colossal entity boasts a combined force of nearly 4,000 lawyers, 800 partners, 48 offices across 29 countries, and a combined revenue of $3.4 billion.

This merger signifies the potential opportunity presented by joining forces with established US firms. It bolsters the general belief that UK firms can no longer rely solely on traditional methods of market entry.

2024: A Year of Opportunity or Continued Struggle?
With the A&O Shearman merger setting a precedent, the year 2024 might witness increased efforts from UK firms to enter the US market. These attempts could take various forms, potentially including:

  • Mergers and acquisitions: Similar to the A&O Shearman example, UK firms could seek strategic mergers with established US firms, leveraging their existing client base and market knowledge.
  • Strategic alliances and partnerships: Collaborative efforts like joint ventures or strategic partnerships with US firms could offer an alternative entry method, allowing access to the market without a full-fledged merger.

While optimism surrounding UK firms' success in the US market is cautiously rising, the road ahead remains uncertain.

Challenges Persist
Several significant challenges continue to hinder UK firms' attempts:

  • Cultural and legal differences: The US legal system and professional culture are distinct from the UK's. Entering the market requires navigating these differences and adapting practices accordingly.
  • Client loyalty: Established US firms enjoy strong client loyalty, making it a challenge for UK firms to entice major clients away.
  • Compensation structures: US law firms traditionally offer higher compensation packages compared to their UK counterparts. Attracting and retaining top talent in the US can be financially demanding for UK firms.

Whether 2024 becomes the year for UK firms to finally conquer the US market remains to be seen. While the A&O Shearman merger offers a glimmer of hope and suggests a potential shift in strategies, significant challenges persist. Only time will tell if UK firms can overcome these hurdles and successfully establish themselves as major players in the US legal landscape.

Knowledge is king

If you would like to keep up to date on the latest industry news and other related content please subscribe to our newsletter.

I agree to receive Taylor Hawkes newsletter and other related communications. privacy policy.

Our Privacy Policy describes how we process your personal data, sets out your rights as a data subject, and identifies how to exercise them.