A New Watchdog On The Block: ARGA And Its Promises

The UK audit market is on the cusp of a significant transformation. The arrival of the Audit, Reporting and Governance Authority (ARGA) promises a wave of changes, impacting regulations, competition, and ultimately, the way audits are conducted. This article delves into the potential implications of ARGA, dissecting its impact on audit regulations, competition in the market, and the daily practices of auditors themselves.

Updated: 13th June 2024

The FRC, the current regulator of the audit market, has faced criticism for its perceived leniency towards the "Big Four" accounting firms (PwC, Deloitte, KPMG, and EY). Enter ARGA, a proposed body with a more robust regulatory framework and a focus on enhancing audit quality and market competition.

The exact details of ARGA's powers are still under development, but potential changes include:

  • Stricter Regulations: ARGA might implement stricter audit standards and impose harsher penalties for non-compliance. This could incentivise a more rigorous audit approach.
  • Market Share Caps: ARGA might introduce market share caps for the Big Four, limiting their dominance and fostering competition from smaller audit firms. This could create a more diverse and potentially more affordable audit market.
  • Operational Separation: ARGA might mandate operational separation of the Big Four's audit and consulting arms, potentially reducing conflicts of interest and enhancing auditor independence.

A More Competitive Landscape: The Rise of Challengers
One of ARGA's key objectives is to foster competition. Market share caps and stricter regulations might pave the way for challenger firms to gain traction. Here's how this could play out:

  • Increased Choice for Companies: With more players in the market, companies could have a wider range of audit firms to choose from, potentially leading to more competitive fees and a broader range of expertise available.
  • Focus on Specialisation: Challenger firms might specialise in specific industry sectors, potentially offering more tailored and in-depth audit services compared to the Big Four's broad service offerings.
  • Innovation and Technology: Increased competition could spur innovation in audit methodologies and the use of technology, potentially leading to more efficient and effective audits.

The Evolving Role of the Auditor: Adapting to a New Era
With stricter regulations and potentially new players in the market, how might the daily practices of auditors themselves be impacted?

  • Deeper Dives: Stricter regulations might necessitate more in-depth and time-consuming audit procedures to ensure compliance. This could impact audit timeframes and potentially costs.
  • Tech-Savvy Auditors: The use of data analytics and artificial intelligence (AI) tools in audits is likely to increase. Auditors might need to develop tech skills to leverage these tools effectively.
  • Stronger Communication: With a focus on audit quality and transparency, auditors might need to improve communication with company management and stakeholders.

The Road Ahead: Embracing Change and Collaboration
The arrival of ARGA marks a significant shift in the UK audit landscape. While there are uncertainties, opportunities also abound. Here's how both audit firms and companies can prepare for the changing tide:

  • Embracing Technology: Investing in tech solutions can streamline audit processes and enhance data analysis capabilities.
  • Building Expertise: Both Big Four and challenger firms should focus on developing deep industry knowledge to cater to specific client needs.
  • Collaborative Mindset: Auditors and company management need to work together openly and transparently to ensure a smooth and effective audit process.

Conclusion: A Brighter Future for Audits?
The arrival of ARGA presents both challenges and opportunities for the UK audit market. While stricter regulations and increased competition might demand adaptation from auditors, the potential outcomes – improved audit quality, a more diverse market, and enhanced transparency – are all positive developments for stakeholders. By embracing change, upskilling, and fostering collaboration, auditors and companies can navigate the evolving landscape and contribute to a brighter future for UK audits.

Knowledge is king

If you would like to keep up to date on the latest industry news and other related content please subscribe to our newsletter.

I agree to receive Taylor Hawkes newsletter and other related communications. privacy policy.

Our Privacy Policy describes how we process your personal data, sets out your rights as a data subject, and identifies how to exercise them.