The Metaverse: Lawless Frontier Or Coded Colosseum? Who Makes The Rules?

The Metaverse, where virtual land deals eclipse real estate, cryptocurrencies challenge traditional finance, and avatars negotiate contracts in digital courtrooms. But who sets the boundaries in this uncharted territory?

Updated: 5th February 2024

As accountants grapple with valuing virtual assets, lawyers untangle the complexities of digital ownership, and bankers navigate the uncharted seas of Decentralised Finance, one question burns bright: are we hurtling towards a lawless free-for-all? , or will it be governed by yet-to-be-written rules? This is not just a technological transformation, but a fundamental reshaping of how entire industries operate, and the fight for control has only just begun.

Accounting Regulations and guidance
While no specific regulations or directions directly address the metaverse's impact on the accountancy profession, organisations and regulatory bodies are acknowledging its potential and taking proactive steps.

General Awareness and Recognition

  • International Federation of Accountants (IFAC): Published a report titled "Technology in Accounting: The Profession in 2040" that mentions the metaverse as a key emerging technology impacting accountants.
  • ACCA (Association of Chartered Certified Accountants): Released articles like "Welcome to the metaverse" and "Get ready for the metaverse" highlighting potential implications for accountants.
  • American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA): Held discussions and published articles exploring the potential impact of the metaverse on accounting practices.

Focus on Adaptability and Skill Development

  • ACCA, AICPA, and other institutes: Emphasises the need for accountants to develop new skills in blockchain technology, cybersecurity, and other relevant areas to adapt to the metaverse.
  • Future of Accounting Taskforce: Supported by ACCA and other bodies, this taskforce identifies future trends like the metaverse and recommends accountants learn new skills like data analysis and critical thinking.

Specific Examples of Potential Impacts

  • Virtual Asset Valuation and Auditing: New service areas might emerge for accountants, requiring expertise in valuing virtual assets and auditing metaverse-based transactions.
  • Decentralised Finance (DeFi): Understanding DeFi protocols and their accounting implications will be crucial for accountants advising clients operating in this space.
  • Data Privacy and Security: Accountants involved in the metaverse will need to navigate complex data privacy and security regulations specific to virtual environments.

Overall Message
Organisations and regulatory bodies encourage accountants to:

  • Stay informed: Keep up with developments in the metaverse and its impact on the accounting profession.
  • Embrace continuous learning: Acquire new skills and knowledge relevant to the evolving digital landscape.
  • Adapt their services: Tailor their services to cater to the needs of businesses operating in the metaverse.


  • ACCA CPD resources: Explore resources covering blockchain, AI, and other emerging technologies.
  • Professional development resources offered by your local CPA body: Check for courses, workshops, or webinars focusing on the metaverse and its implications for accountants.
  • Future of Accounting Taskforce reports: Gain insights into future trends and recommended skills.
  • Regulatory body websites: Stay updated on official statements and guidance related to the metaverse.

Legal Regulations and guidance
As with the accountancy profession, organisations and regulatory bodies overseeing the legal profession haven't issued specific directions or instructions regarding the metaverse. However, they are acknowledging its potential impact and taking initial steps to prepare and inform legal professionals. Here's a breakdown:

Awareness and Recognition

  • American Bar Association (ABA): Established a working group dedicated to exploring the legal implications of the metaverse, focusing on areas like intellectual property, privacy, and ethics.
  • Law Society of England and Wales (LSEW): Formed a "Lawtech Futures" team to analyse emerging technologies, including the metaverse, and their impact on the legal profession.
  • International Bar Association (IBA): Held conferences and published articles discussing legal issues within the metaverse, such as jurisdiction, dispute resolution, and data protection.

Focus on Adaptability and Upskilling

  • ABA Centre for Professional Responsibility: Urges lawyers to update their ethics code to address potential issues arising in the metaverse, like virtual interactions and client representation.
  • LSEW Tech Report 2022: Highlights the need for lawyers to develop skills in emerging technologies like AI and blockchain, relevant to working within the metaverse.
  • IBA Legal Technology Committee: Encourages collaboration between lawyers, technologists, and regulators to explore and adapt legal frameworks for the metaverse.

Specific Areas of Impact

  • Intellectual Property: Protecting intellectual property like trademarks and copyrights within virtual worlds poses new challenges requiring legal expertise.
  • Data Privacy and Security: Ensuring user data privacy and security in virtual environments necessitates adapting existing legal frameworks.
  • Contracts and Dispute Resolution: Drafting and enforcing contracts within the metaverse, along with resolving disputes in virtual spaces, demands specialised legal knowledge.
  • Ethics and Regulation: Developing ethical guidelines and regulatory frameworks for legal practice within the metaverse is crucial.

Overall Message

Organisations and regulatory bodies encourage legal professionals to:

  • Stay informed: Keep up with the evolving legal landscape in the metaverse.
  • Embrace continuous learning: Acquire new skills in technology, data privacy, and virtual world dynamics.
  • Advocate for clear regulations: Actively engage in shaping legal frameworks for responsible practices in the metaverse.
  • Collaborate with stakeholders: Work with technologists, regulators, and other professionals to address emerging challenges.


  • ABA Technology Resource Centre: Explore their "Metaverse & Web3" section for updates and resources.
  • LSEW Tech Report 2022: Read their analysis of emerging technologies and the legal profession.
  • IBA Legal Technology Committee website: Find information on conferences and initiatives exploring legal issues in the metaverse.

Banking Regulations and guidance

While the metaverse is still in its early stages of development, there haven't been any direct regulations or legislation specifically targeting the metaverse issued by the organisations such as SEC, FCA, ESMA, etc. This is because many aspects of the metaverse are still undefined and evolving rapidly. However, some existing regulations and frameworks may indirectly apply to specific metaverse activities and could be adapted in the future as the metaverse matures. Here are some key points to consider.

Existing Regulations

  • Securities: Existing securities regulations may apply to activities like tokenised assets, virtual currencies, and NFTs traded within the metaverse. Regulators are currently evaluating how these existing frameworks can be adapted to new asset classes and trading structures in the metaverse.
  • Consumer Protection: Regulations aimed at consumer protection and data privacy will likely be relevant to interactions within the metaverse, including issues like user identification, virtual advertising, and potential risks of fraud or exploitation.
  • Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Know Your Customer (KYC): Existing AML/KYC requirements might need to be adapted to address potential money laundering risks associated with virtual currencies and financial transactions within the metaverse.

Regulator Initiatives

  • Regulatory Sandboxes: Several regulators are creating sandbox environments where financial institutions and technology companies can test innovative financial products and services, including those related to the metaverse, in a controlled setting. This allows regulators to learn more about the potential risks and benefits before issuing specific regulations.
  • Guidance and Statements: Some regulators have issued statements or guidance documents highlighting potential risks and considerations related to the metaverse, but these don't constitute formal regulations.

Challenges and Future Developments

  • Jurisdictional Uncertainty: The global nature of the metaverse raises questions about which regulations apply in different jurisdictions, creating potential challenges for businesses and regulators.
  • Technological Evolution: The rapid pace of technological development in the metaverse may necessitate adapting regulations and legislation to keep pace with new functionalities and risks.
  • Collaboration: Close collaboration between regulators, policymakers, and industry players will be crucial to develop effective regulatory frameworks for the metaverse that foster innovation while protecting consumers and ensuring financial stability.

Overall, while no direct regulations exist yet, the business world continues to closely monitor the metaverse and is taking steps to prepare for its potential impact. It's an evolving space, and we can expect more specific regulations and legislation to emerge as the metaverse develops further.


Does the Metaverse threaten traditional M&A

Mergers & Metaverses: Are early movers shaping the future?

Considering a financial career embracing the metaverse?

Knowledge is king

If you would like to keep up to date on the latest industry news and other related content please subscribe to our newsletter.

I agree to receive Taylor Hawkes newsletter and other related communications. privacy policy.

Our Privacy Policy describes how we process your personal data, sets out your rights as a data subject, and identifies how to exercise them.